Wednesday, December 24, 2014
The SONY Situation
“Behind the phony tinsel of Hollywood
lies the real tinsel.” Oscar Levant, (1906 - 1972)
As someone who strongly
believes in the importance of free speech and uncensored creative expression, I
have of course been extremely interested in and concerned about the “SONY
Situation.” This is extremely important because it’s about a whole lot more
than a controversial movie. It is a seminal 21st Century dilemma: the
first major confluence of new technology, violent and cyber terrorism, the traditional
American definition of Democracy, culture clash, Capitalism, electronic news
media, and human behavior in the still-developing “new normal.” This is a big subject
but I’ll tackle what I can in this post.
I started writing this
post at least a week ago, and there have been new developments in the past
couple of days. So to summarize the incident that provoked an international
mess: SONY, a giant American entertainment company, was grievously cyber attacked
by North Korean extremists (and possibly the NK government itself) because it
produced a satirical comedy film about the assassination of the real-life,
sitting, North Korean president, Kim Jong-un. The news media ill-advisedly but
not surprisingly focused on the celebrity gossip revealed by the hack-attack
instead of the depth and implications of the attack itself.
Then, SONY and America were
threatened with 9/11-scale attacks against movie theaters if the film was
released. All of the country’s theater chains united in their refusal to show the
film; Sony announced it would not release the film (like they had a choice,
once the theaters decided not to show it); and much of the film industry and
some politicians, including President Obama, criticized SONY for giving in to
threats, because nobody can tell us what kind of movies we can and cannot make,
and, America shouldn’t surrender its core freedoms out of fear.
The irony is we already have surrendered some of our core
freedoms out of fear. America was rattled to its previously complacent bones by
the 9/11 attacks, though we were determined not to let it show. President John
Wayne Bush stood on the World Trade Center rubble and literally told the terrorists to “bring it on,” to prove that our
national balls, pride, and courage were undefeatably enormous.
But a few weeks
later, Congress and the Senate passed the Patriot Act with whiplash speed. It
is still in place, giving the government’s numerous intelligence and
security agencies unprecedented permission to spy, bug, physically gather, and
in other ways obtain private information about individuals, to basically do
whatever they deem necessary to whomever they regard as suspicious in the name of national security.
Some Americans and some
organizations objected. In the minority quarters that value privacy and civil
rights for individuals, Ben Franklin’s sage quotation: They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary
safety deserve neither liberty nor safety was dusted off and given new exposure.
But it didn’t change anything because it turns out that most Americans are willing to exchange “essential
liberty” (privacy, free speech, creative expression, etc.) for whatever sense
of safety they can secure.
In the last few days, the
country and the companies (SONY and the theaters) seem to have decided to
macho-man-up again. President Obama asked China to do what they can to keep North
Korea in check. It was suggested that North Korea be added to our official
“watch” list of nations/organizations most likely to attempt a terrorist
attack, though at this moment I don’t know if that’s been done. Some theaters
decided to change their corporate minds about showing the film, and SONY, it
appears, has changed its mind about releasing it, even if it will be a more
limited release than originally planned. For a Christmas Day debut. Merry Christmas.
Now we come to our
national love affair with technology – which is really just our most recent infatuation
with a big, shiny, major new toy, a love that knows no bounds and sees no downside
until the initial glow wears off, and that process can take quite a while. We embraced
the Information Age with the same passion we lavished on the Industrial
Revolution.
I’m not saying America or
the world would all be better off living like the Amish. I’m just pointing out
that we have a history of plunging into the seductive technically new in the
present, without regard for its impact on what we value from the past, or
anticipating the potential disadvantages of the presently new in the future.
This is especially concerning now as we further explore artificial intelligence
and robotics in a spirit of childlike wonder.
Through technology, what
used to be a great big world has, from the 19th Century on, become a
much smaller one. Throw differing religions, cultures, economics and politics
into the mix and it becomes quite a muddle. Add poor education, increased poverty,
huge gaps in human rights and civil rights, terrorism, war and other forms of armed
conflict, environmental change, and population growth, and you have the complex
quagmire we call Now.
So, in regard to the “Sony
Situation,” I believe that our 18th Century ideas of what Freedom
and Democracy allow for were and are rightly challenged, not just by outside anger and danger, but also by a certain measure of contemporary
common sense as well. In every discussion of free speech, it is pointed out
that while people should have an unfettered right to express their ideas and
opinions, they don’t have the right to be irresponsible – such as shouting
Fire! Fire! in a crowded movie theater when there is no fire.
I am of the opinion that
in this day and age, producing a
major motion picture about the assassination of any named, real-life, sitting president of any country – even a bizarre
little despot like Kim Jong-un – is the creative equivalent of Fire! Fire!,
especially when you consider that totalitarian dictators and the populations
they rule have no working concept of humor, let alone satire. And just because
one has the right and freedom to do something doesn’t mean it’s a good idea to
do it.
What would the American
response be if a foreign country – say France, England or Australia, all of
which have thriving film industries, unlike our chief national enemies – made a
satirical comedy about the assassination of the named, specific, actual Barack
Obama? The President himself, who has a great sense of humor and understands
the concept of satire, would probably just roll with the punches as he has with
everything that’s been thrown at him.
But I doubt Mrs. Obama would appreciate it, nor would the Democratic Party, nor
would many Americans who support, even love, the President. We wouldn’t be
hearing about free speech and creative freedom in that scenario.
The “SONY Situation” puts the
company, the film industry, and the government in the satirically comic
position of having to defend a film that shouldn’t have been made in the first
place, in the name of free speech, creative freedom, and not allowing other
countries to push us around. Why? In no small part because of Capitalism.
America’s leading export is entertainment: film, television, music, video games
and increasingly stand-up comedy. And for many years now, Hollywood product in
all categories has been built on a foundation of graphic violence, drugs and
sex.
So when our government
tells us that terrorists hate us for our freedom, that is only part of the
truth. They also hate us for the nature and content of our popular culture, our
military intervention in their countries, and our constant efforts at regime
change (what we like to call nation building). We are determined to spread
Democracy and Capitalism, two different things that many Americans think are
the same.
I know there are critical
human rights issues at stake, but it’s not a simple matter to resolve and we
tend to make our efforts to fix and change things in a manner that other
countries find decidedly objectionable. They think we’re crazy, just as we
think they’re crazy. I do think they’re much crazier than we are. However, we
have little with which to defend ourselves. Because our other top export is
Consumerism – in concept and action. Ours is a youth-&-beauty-obsessed,
celebrity-worshiping, materialistic culture. We value money, power, prestige and
things more than people. We are the
least developed nation among all developed nations when it comes to economic
equality, education, health care, and our regard for the poor and elderly.
I think the current
defense of The Interview, filled with
Constitutional dismay about SONY’s initial response, is misplaced: the right
defense for the wrong thing. Where was a similar torrent of outrage when NewSouth
Books put a fig leaf on Huckleberry Finn
by changing the use of “nigger” to “slave,” even though this is a classic work
of fiction that reflects the accurate, actual use of language in its historical
place in time?
Hasn’t the rigidity of political correctness also
mindlessly and uncreatively undermined free speech and creative expression? Comedian Lenny Bruce, poet Allen Ginsberg, and photographer Robert
Mapplethorpe were never given the succor of the First Amendment in their time,
even though they richly deserved it. The "SONY Situation" requires a lot of
thought and deserves much intelligent discussion – but The Interview is a regrettable launch pad for it.
Posted by MizB at 6:13 AM 0 comments
Wednesday, December 10, 2014
How Many Light Bulbs Does It Take To Change America?
Don Henley’s “The End of the Innocence”
is playing as I write this because for the last few weeks (and more) that’s
what’s happened for a lot us – those of us paying attention, those of us who don’t
have the money or the heart to get lost in the Christmas hustle that feels so unimportant
and unreal this year. We as a nation have been awash in waves of shame and
pride: our own, each others, those of leaders and idols and ordinary people
turned into symbols they never wanted to be.
Yesterday’s CIA “Torture
Report” was so revolting it actually inspired bipartisan anger and shame in the
Senate. We already knew “intensified interrogation techniques” (G-d save us
from the danger of euphemisms) had been used after the 9/11 terrorist attacks
in the governmental zeal to preempt further assaults. But we didn’t how deeply,
cruelly “intensified” they were, or for how long they went on, against so many
people, and how ineptly and chaotically the process was handled. “This isn’t
who we are,” said an aggrieved President Obama about the program approved by
his predecessor. But it is. It’s a big part of who we are and have always been,
in spirit, from the genocide of the Indians through Slavery, Jim Crow, Vietnam,
and the deeply divided country we’ve become.
And from Ferguson to
Staten Island to Cleveland (among others), the recent racial conflicts between
police and young Black men (and a child) have made it plain that largely White
law enforcement still doesn’t know how to cope with Black communities; that the
Judicial System is equally broken and ignorant; and that Americans of all ages
and colors are still capable of uniting in peaceful, nonviolent protest against
the cancer of racism. Dirty waves of shame, cleansing waves of pride.
A lot of people – mostly White – thought the election of President Obama showed that racism was over in
America, an idea that would be hilarious if it weren’t so treacherously untrue.
I recall the young, rousing, Barack Obama speaking at the 2004 Democratic
Convention saying there was no Black America or White America, just One America.
I understood how much he wanted that to be so. I too am biracial and when I was
still quite young, I believed it was my destiny, my responsibility, to be a
communicator and a racial unifier, because I had a foot in both worlds. I never
did figure out how to do that and, it turns out, neither has Barack Obama, even
though he’s a whole lot smarter than I am and worked a million times harder.
The unfortunate, revealing,
truth is Obama’s election fueled a resurgence of rampant, outspoken,
unapologetic racism. I’m sure he expected some push-back, but I think even he
was taken off-guard by how forceful it’s been. I don’t think he expected it
would grind Congress to a halt, or lead a right-slanted Supreme Court to eviscerate
the Voting Rights Act in the midst of a nationwide Voter Suppression Movement,
or that he would be called an illegitimate president who is behaving like a
king because he’s done the same kinds of things the White presidents did –
mainly, behaving like The President.
As we enter a two-year
campaign for the 2016 presidential election (please, shoot me now), the pundits are discussing the Obama Legacy, as if it can be assessed just like any
other presidency. His legacy, for the record, is that he kept us out of another
Great Depression, re-grew the economy quite impressively with no help from
either house of Congress, achieved a first attempt at something resembling
national health care insurance even though it’s woefully sloppy and
over-detailed, accomplished a bushel of things few people either know about or
remember (take a look at the White House website), appointed two progressive
women to the Supreme Court, conducted himself with presidential dignity in the
face of consistent disrespect, managed to get re-elected and be a two-term
president, and to date has avoided assassination, even though, it would appear,
the Secret Service doesn’t entirely have his back.
I guess we’ll have to [hope and] wait for Hillary Clinton. Maybe she can do something about “race relations,” since paying any attention to women’s issues would clearly be favoritism. Shame and pride, pride and shame, and the increased loss of personal and national innocence as the eternal foibles of reality bubble up. And I don’t even have room left to talk about Bill Cosby.
Posted by MizB at 9:55 AM 1 comments
Sunday, November 09, 2014
Solutions
It’s a cool, dry, late
Sunday morning here in New York City and if I had the emotional strength, I
could be watching the major, weekly political talk shows (Meet the Press and such) that are no doubt now taking the “long
view” perspective on Tuesday’s election (in 21st century time,
that’s five days later instead of five minutes later). But I have my own long
view perspective, and, I’ve received several emails over the past few days
offering very specific approaches to what ails us as a nation, the contents of
which I want to share with you. They show that there is hope, there are things
everyone can do.
My own perspective is that
what will happen legislatively over the next two years is anybody’s guess,
because the Republicans are not going to stop being who they are – although it appears that the less wildly crazy wing
of the party seems to now be in charge. But their core allegiance to the rich
and corporate, and their inbred lack of understanding and concern for everyone
and everything else, remains intact.
The President, while being
genuinely willing to negotiate and compromise – which he has been willing to do
since Day One, while the Republicans have been busy hating him and obstructing
everything he’s tried to do – is, I believe, also more intent on pushing
forward with the things he actually believes in, the things he hasn’t
heretofore been very aggressive about, to the consternation of his Progressive
base. So what will actually happen is a crap shoot and will no doubt be
interesting and aggravating to watch.
Fortunately, there are
people out there, people with actual political power, who see some
opportunities for Democrats (legislators and ordinary citizens alike) to get
their act together and begin to articulate a cohesive message as they move through the molasses-paced 2016
campaign that has already begun, with a simple and sensible agenda.
My first email came from
the Progressive
Change Campaign Committee, which published an op-ed on the political
website, The
Hill, entitled “Route to Power for Democrats: Big Ideas,” which espouses
the reasonable, progressive, Sen.
Elizabeth Warren agenda of “taking on Wall Street, reducing student debt,
and expanding Social Security benefits,” as a primary message that all practical
working people can get behind.
The second message came from
Sen. Bernie Sanders, whose primary
message is that the influence of Big Money in politics (a privilege for the
rich so smoothly sanctioned by the Supreme Court’s legitimization of the democracy-busting
Citizen’s
United fundraising operation) must be eradicated. He also stresses that the
enormity of Income Inequality, which pits the tiny but extraordinarily wealthy
Billionaire Class (several hundred families holding 95% of the nation’s wealth)
against the rest of us (that famous, or infamous, 1% vs. 99% equation) must be
balanced with significant tax reform, a stronger labor movement, and a
federally-increased minimum wage.
To increase public involvement in and support
for this agenda, one of the many things Sen. Sanders is doing is proposing that
Election Day be made a Federal Holiday called Democracy Day to promote the
meaning and importance of democracy and the vital role that ordinary folks play
in it by voting (and making it easier to vote because as a federal holiday,
people will get a paid day off from work). He has proposed a bill and created a
petition that you can sign.
Indeed, if you click on all the links in this blog post you will learn a lot more about how progressive Democrats and Independents (and maybe even secretly-rational Republicans) can work from this important point forward to avoid the United States of America turning into a full-scale oligarchy disaster.
Posted by MizB at 1:25 PM 1 comments
Wednesday, November 05, 2014
Now What?
I watched British
mysteries on PBS until 11:00 last night, because I didn’t want to see election
returns until there was more certainty about the results. When I finally clicked
onto MSNBC, everyone was talking so fast and so much was flashing quickly on
and off the screen that it took me a few minutes to understand what was going
on – but it didn’t take too long. Democrats had been creamed from coast to
coast. There were renewed and additional Republican Governors; more Republicans
in the House with an increase in Tea Party crazies; and indeed, the Republicans
had taken over the Senate.
Today, those of us who
were listening heard Mitch McConnell (by political necessity) and President Obama (by
leadership responsibility) talk about working together more
productively on issues about which they can find some measure of common
ground – chiefly immigration reform, infrastructure repair, and foreign trade
(according to the President). But neither of these leopards has changed his
ideological spots. McConnell is no friend of the common (wo)man or liberal
ideals, and the President is still firm on general health care, the
funding of the “Big 3” benefit programs (Social Security, Medicare, and
Medicaid) and environmental realities – including, of course, climate change.
I’ve also been watching
political analysis throughout the day and there seems to be general agreement
that there will be less gridlock and more actual governance than the
Republicans have allowed over the past six years; that the Republicans
successfully communicated the idea that the nation’s ills were the President’s
fault and managed to avoid addressing real issues at all; and that the
Democrats shot themselves in their fractured, disconnected feet by not unifying
behind the President’s considerable achievements. It was also felt that those
Americans who voted, as well as those who didn’t, were both expressing their
anger with what has become the dysfunctional status quo.
What politicians in both parties will do from hereon in remains to be seen. But what
can we, as citizens, do to influence their actions? I didn’t hear/read any
discussion of this, which I find both peculiar and unfortunate. Because in the
final analysis, all politicians want votes. They spend huge amounts of money to
get votes and accept that money from some very questionable characters.
Ironically and importantly, many, if not most, Americans are not political junkies. Many Democrats
campaigned on the dangers of Big Money in politics, in particular the bedeviled
influence of the Koch Brothers. Apparently most people don’t know who they are
or care. And many people don’t connect the dots between their own hard times
and Big Money, its key reactionary donors, and the ever-increasing wealth of
the 1% (there are now twice as many billionaires as there were before the
2008 crash).
If I thought a well conceived and efficiently organized Liberal Revolution were possible, I’d advocate for one. Alas, I don’t think it is, so I don’t. Instead, under the heading “Now What?” I advocate the following: (1) pay closer attention to the news, get your news from more than one source, and start connecting the dots (2) write to everyone in your political world: Mayor, City Council President, State Senator & Assembly-person, U.S. Congress-person & Senators, and the President. Tell them what issues you care about, both the ones that affect you directly and the rest that you recognize affect us all as a nation and as citizens of the world, and (3) remember that democracy is a living, breathing thing made up of all of us thinking critically and participating in the political process. Use the next two years to get ready and in 2016 be fully aware of what’s what and what’s right and vote accordingly. It’s the only real shot we’ve got.
Posted by MizB at 9:28 PM 1 comments
Monday, November 03, 2014
I Know, But PLEASE Vote Anyway!
When I think of the brave
efforts made and terrible horrors endured by both the Suffragists of the early
20th century and the Civil Rights activists of the 50s and 60s so that
women and blacks could secure the right to vote, it makes me very sad that so
many people today have come to view voting as pointless.
I do understand why. Our
governments – locally, statewide and federally – have become completely
co-opted by Big Money: corporations, lobbyists for various industries, and rich
individuals, whose only concerns are maintaining and furthering their own
interests. In both houses of Congress, the vast majority of Representatives and
Senators are (1) male, (2) white and (3) millionaires, multi-millionaires and a
few billionaires. Their concern seems to be getting elected (and re-elected) to
their cushy jobs with good salaries (everyone needs pin money), extraordinary
benefits & perks, and very brief actual-work periods.
The Republicans, once a
stodgy party interested primarily in minimal government spending and low taxes
for the upper middle class and rich (when rich wasn’t yet obscenely über
wealthy), has moved so far to the Lunatic Fringe Right and Ultra Conservative
that they have zero concern for
anybody’s human rights, civil rights, health & well-being, education, or
anything else that should accompany citizenship for all citizens. In the name
of Christianity (which shouldn’t even be in the picture!), they’ve decided that
they and they alone hold the moral high ground on every conceivable issue. And
ever since the election of America’s first black President, all that has been
transparent is their racism and determination to prevent him from functioning –
and they’ve made a good job of it!
But perhaps even more
disappointing are the Democrats. We know who and what the Republicans are. But
who and what are the Democrats? They’re disconnected from each other; generally
cowardly when it comes to speaking to and acting against any sort of
formidable, oppositional power; they have been unsupportive of their own
President; and as a result of all this, have failed utterly to combat the 1% on
behalf of the rest of us. They appear to be a bit more willing and able to rise
to the occasion for this critical mid-term election and the endless campaign
for the 2016 Presidency that will immediately follow, but still, it is indeed
hard to work up a whole lot of enthusiasm for them.
If you don’t want to render President Obama completely impotent for the next two years, the Democrats, for all their weaknesses, must NOT lose control of the Senate. There are opportunities nationwide to get rid of some entrenched Republican Congressional representatives or avoid new ones. There are critical Governorships and State Senatorial races. There are important Propositions on the ballots of many states. There is an opportunity tomorrow to show by our numbers that we’re here and we do care about the governments we have. We may not be able to make great strides this time around, but we can rattle the status quo – perhaps just enough to enlarge Democratic balls and impact for 2016. Don’t give up yet. Please vote tomorrow and give what’s left of American democracy a fighting chance.
Posted by MizB at 4:22 PM 0 comments
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




