I don’t know what the lasting impact of the diverse events and language of the last couple of weeks will be for me – or others. I don’t know how I’ll feel or think or what tone my writing will take, especially as the 300-year campaign of the 2016 election moves glacially along. But whatever people’s different feelings about all this may be, none of us can deny that something extraordinary has happened. And that in itself is amazing.
Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts
Sunday, June 28, 2015
Amazing Grace
If you did not see or read
President Obama’s eulogy for Rev./SC State Sen. Clementa Pinckney on Thursday
afternoon, you missed something unique and magnificent. The perspective of the
President’s language was very Christian because he himself is very Christian
and he was offering a eulogy about a minister, so that’s not surprising. But
his tribute was particularly eloquent and filled with messages of basic
humanism, the possibility for the evolution of human kindness, historic truth, common
sense, and social and political necessity, all of which was entirely
appropriate in the context of the eulogy and the time in which we live. If you
missed it, I encourage you to click on one of the links above.
The President’s core
message was that we are blessed by God with grace – the grace to be good people;
people capable of love and forgiveness even in response to the most vile
wrong-doing and the most heart wrenching grief; and that if we can learn how to
live our lives and view others with a more open heart, anything and everything
good is possible. Even if you take God out of that scenario and simply view the
capacity for grace as something that is a central part of our DNA which we can
choose to cultivate or ignore, the message still rings true and is worthy of
contemplation and discussion.
As my regular readers
know, I embody a great deal of anger, cynicism, and hardcore judgment about
things and circumstances I don’t like. I apply this rancor to all the subjects
this blog is primarily about: politics, contemporary culture, new technology,
and the ruination of the English language. I try to reveal the sense of humor I
have that keeps me relatively sane and has so far prevented me from committing
acts of violence. But I’ve also discussed my considerable depression and
misery.
Over the past couple of days,
I’ve twice watched the President deliver the eulogy and read the text once.
Besides increasing my respect and affection for him, I’ve thought
a lot about the lack of grace I’ve cultivated within myself and wondered (1) if
I have the ability to do so and (2) if even the effort would give me a greater
sense of inner peace if not outright love, happiness and joy. I don’t know the
answer, but I admit that I fear the process, not because of its difficulty, but
because I’ve clung to these feelings like a teddy bear for decades.
Indeed, they remind me of a
great Robin Williams scene in Moscow On
the Hudson, in which he plays a foreign musician and he’s just jammed with
a blues band and is talking to one of the American musicians: “When I was in Russia, I did not love my
life, but I loved my misery. You know why? Because it was my misery. I
could hold it. I could caress it. I loved my misery. You know, I have a whole
family I will never ever see again. You see? Now you see. You know it. There it
is. Now you know that the saddest thing in the world is life. Yeah, man. Now
you see. Thank you. Thank you for a wonderful night. Boy, I feel great. Take
care. I love you.” “If that was
wonderful, what happens when he hits deep depression?”
I don’t know what the lasting impact of the diverse events and language of the last couple of weeks will be for me – or others. I don’t know how I’ll feel or think or what tone my writing will take, especially as the 300-year campaign of the 2016 election moves glacially along. But whatever people’s different feelings about all this may be, none of us can deny that something extraordinary has happened. And that in itself is amazing.
Posted by MizB at 1:52 PM 2 comments
Wednesday, December 24, 2014
The SONY Situation
“Behind the phony tinsel of Hollywood
lies the real tinsel.” Oscar Levant, (1906 - 1972)
As someone who strongly
believes in the importance of free speech and uncensored creative expression, I
have of course been extremely interested in and concerned about the “SONY
Situation.” This is extremely important because it’s about a whole lot more
than a controversial movie. It is a seminal 21st Century dilemma: the
first major confluence of new technology, violent and cyber terrorism, the traditional
American definition of Democracy, culture clash, Capitalism, electronic news
media, and human behavior in the still-developing “new normal.” This is a big subject
but I’ll tackle what I can in this post.
I started writing this
post at least a week ago, and there have been new developments in the past
couple of days. So to summarize the incident that provoked an international
mess: SONY, a giant American entertainment company, was grievously cyber attacked
by North Korean extremists (and possibly the NK government itself) because it
produced a satirical comedy film about the assassination of the real-life,
sitting, North Korean president, Kim Jong-un. The news media ill-advisedly but
not surprisingly focused on the celebrity gossip revealed by the hack-attack
instead of the depth and implications of the attack itself.
Then, SONY and America were
threatened with 9/11-scale attacks against movie theaters if the film was
released. All of the country’s theater chains united in their refusal to show the
film; Sony announced it would not release the film (like they had a choice,
once the theaters decided not to show it); and much of the film industry and
some politicians, including President Obama, criticized SONY for giving in to
threats, because nobody can tell us what kind of movies we can and cannot make,
and, America shouldn’t surrender its core freedoms out of fear.
The irony is we already have surrendered some of our core
freedoms out of fear. America was rattled to its previously complacent bones by
the 9/11 attacks, though we were determined not to let it show. President John
Wayne Bush stood on the World Trade Center rubble and literally told the terrorists to “bring it on,” to prove that our
national balls, pride, and courage were undefeatably enormous.
But a few weeks
later, Congress and the Senate passed the Patriot Act with whiplash speed. It
is still in place, giving the government’s numerous intelligence and
security agencies unprecedented permission to spy, bug, physically gather, and
in other ways obtain private information about individuals, to basically do
whatever they deem necessary to whomever they regard as suspicious in the name of national security.
Some Americans and some
organizations objected. In the minority quarters that value privacy and civil
rights for individuals, Ben Franklin’s sage quotation: They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary
safety deserve neither liberty nor safety was dusted off and given new exposure.
But it didn’t change anything because it turns out that most Americans are willing to exchange “essential
liberty” (privacy, free speech, creative expression, etc.) for whatever sense
of safety they can secure.
In the last few days, the
country and the companies (SONY and the theaters) seem to have decided to
macho-man-up again. President Obama asked China to do what they can to keep North
Korea in check. It was suggested that North Korea be added to our official
“watch” list of nations/organizations most likely to attempt a terrorist
attack, though at this moment I don’t know if that’s been done. Some theaters
decided to change their corporate minds about showing the film, and SONY, it
appears, has changed its mind about releasing it, even if it will be a more
limited release than originally planned. For a Christmas Day debut. Merry Christmas.
Now we come to our
national love affair with technology – which is really just our most recent infatuation
with a big, shiny, major new toy, a love that knows no bounds and sees no downside
until the initial glow wears off, and that process can take quite a while. We embraced
the Information Age with the same passion we lavished on the Industrial
Revolution.
I’m not saying America or
the world would all be better off living like the Amish. I’m just pointing out
that we have a history of plunging into the seductive technically new in the
present, without regard for its impact on what we value from the past, or
anticipating the potential disadvantages of the presently new in the future.
This is especially concerning now as we further explore artificial intelligence
and robotics in a spirit of childlike wonder.
Through technology, what
used to be a great big world has, from the 19th Century on, become a
much smaller one. Throw differing religions, cultures, economics and politics
into the mix and it becomes quite a muddle. Add poor education, increased poverty,
huge gaps in human rights and civil rights, terrorism, war and other forms of armed
conflict, environmental change, and population growth, and you have the complex
quagmire we call Now.
So, in regard to the “Sony
Situation,” I believe that our 18th Century ideas of what Freedom
and Democracy allow for were and are rightly challenged, not just by outside anger and danger, but also by a certain measure of contemporary
common sense as well. In every discussion of free speech, it is pointed out
that while people should have an unfettered right to express their ideas and
opinions, they don’t have the right to be irresponsible – such as shouting
Fire! Fire! in a crowded movie theater when there is no fire.
I am of the opinion that
in this day and age, producing a
major motion picture about the assassination of any named, real-life, sitting president of any country – even a bizarre
little despot like Kim Jong-un – is the creative equivalent of Fire! Fire!,
especially when you consider that totalitarian dictators and the populations
they rule have no working concept of humor, let alone satire. And just because
one has the right and freedom to do something doesn’t mean it’s a good idea to
do it.
What would the American
response be if a foreign country – say France, England or Australia, all of
which have thriving film industries, unlike our chief national enemies – made a
satirical comedy about the assassination of the named, specific, actual Barack
Obama? The President himself, who has a great sense of humor and understands
the concept of satire, would probably just roll with the punches as he has with
everything that’s been thrown at him.
But I doubt Mrs. Obama would appreciate it, nor would the Democratic Party, nor
would many Americans who support, even love, the President. We wouldn’t be
hearing about free speech and creative freedom in that scenario.
The “SONY Situation” puts the
company, the film industry, and the government in the satirically comic
position of having to defend a film that shouldn’t have been made in the first
place, in the name of free speech, creative freedom, and not allowing other
countries to push us around. Why? In no small part because of Capitalism.
America’s leading export is entertainment: film, television, music, video games
and increasingly stand-up comedy. And for many years now, Hollywood product in
all categories has been built on a foundation of graphic violence, drugs and
sex.
So when our government
tells us that terrorists hate us for our freedom, that is only part of the
truth. They also hate us for the nature and content of our popular culture, our
military intervention in their countries, and our constant efforts at regime
change (what we like to call nation building). We are determined to spread
Democracy and Capitalism, two different things that many Americans think are
the same.
I know there are critical
human rights issues at stake, but it’s not a simple matter to resolve and we
tend to make our efforts to fix and change things in a manner that other
countries find decidedly objectionable. They think we’re crazy, just as we
think they’re crazy. I do think they’re much crazier than we are. However, we
have little with which to defend ourselves. Because our other top export is
Consumerism – in concept and action. Ours is a youth-&-beauty-obsessed,
celebrity-worshiping, materialistic culture. We value money, power, prestige and
things more than people. We are the
least developed nation among all developed nations when it comes to economic
equality, education, health care, and our regard for the poor and elderly.
I think the current
defense of The Interview, filled with
Constitutional dismay about SONY’s initial response, is misplaced: the right
defense for the wrong thing. Where was a similar torrent of outrage when NewSouth
Books put a fig leaf on Huckleberry Finn
by changing the use of “nigger” to “slave,” even though this is a classic work
of fiction that reflects the accurate, actual use of language in its historical
place in time?
Hasn’t the rigidity of political correctness also
mindlessly and uncreatively undermined free speech and creative expression? Comedian Lenny Bruce, poet Allen Ginsberg, and photographer Robert
Mapplethorpe were never given the succor of the First Amendment in their time,
even though they richly deserved it. The "SONY Situation" requires a lot of
thought and deserves much intelligent discussion – but The Interview is a regrettable launch pad for it.
Posted by MizB at 6:13 AM 0 comments
Wednesday, November 05, 2014
Now What?
I watched British
mysteries on PBS until 11:00 last night, because I didn’t want to see election
returns until there was more certainty about the results. When I finally clicked
onto MSNBC, everyone was talking so fast and so much was flashing quickly on
and off the screen that it took me a few minutes to understand what was going
on – but it didn’t take too long. Democrats had been creamed from coast to
coast. There were renewed and additional Republican Governors; more Republicans
in the House with an increase in Tea Party crazies; and indeed, the Republicans
had taken over the Senate.
Today, those of us who
were listening heard Mitch McConnell (by political necessity) and President Obama (by
leadership responsibility) talk about working together more
productively on issues about which they can find some measure of common
ground – chiefly immigration reform, infrastructure repair, and foreign trade
(according to the President). But neither of these leopards has changed his
ideological spots. McConnell is no friend of the common (wo)man or liberal
ideals, and the President is still firm on general health care, the
funding of the “Big 3” benefit programs (Social Security, Medicare, and
Medicaid) and environmental realities – including, of course, climate change.
I’ve also been watching
political analysis throughout the day and there seems to be general agreement
that there will be less gridlock and more actual governance than the
Republicans have allowed over the past six years; that the Republicans
successfully communicated the idea that the nation’s ills were the President’s
fault and managed to avoid addressing real issues at all; and that the
Democrats shot themselves in their fractured, disconnected feet by not unifying
behind the President’s considerable achievements. It was also felt that those
Americans who voted, as well as those who didn’t, were both expressing their
anger with what has become the dysfunctional status quo.
What politicians in both parties will do from hereon in remains to be seen. But what
can we, as citizens, do to influence their actions? I didn’t hear/read any
discussion of this, which I find both peculiar and unfortunate. Because in the
final analysis, all politicians want votes. They spend huge amounts of money to
get votes and accept that money from some very questionable characters.
Ironically and importantly, many, if not most, Americans are not political junkies. Many Democrats
campaigned on the dangers of Big Money in politics, in particular the bedeviled
influence of the Koch Brothers. Apparently most people don’t know who they are
or care. And many people don’t connect the dots between their own hard times
and Big Money, its key reactionary donors, and the ever-increasing wealth of
the 1% (there are now twice as many billionaires as there were before the
2008 crash).
If I thought a well conceived and efficiently organized Liberal Revolution were possible, I’d advocate for one. Alas, I don’t think it is, so I don’t. Instead, under the heading “Now What?” I advocate the following: (1) pay closer attention to the news, get your news from more than one source, and start connecting the dots (2) write to everyone in your political world: Mayor, City Council President, State Senator & Assembly-person, U.S. Congress-person & Senators, and the President. Tell them what issues you care about, both the ones that affect you directly and the rest that you recognize affect us all as a nation and as citizens of the world, and (3) remember that democracy is a living, breathing thing made up of all of us thinking critically and participating in the political process. Use the next two years to get ready and in 2016 be fully aware of what’s what and what’s right and vote accordingly. It’s the only real shot we’ve got.
Posted by MizB at 9:28 PM 1 comments
Monday, November 03, 2014
I Know, But PLEASE Vote Anyway!
When I think of the brave
efforts made and terrible horrors endured by both the Suffragists of the early
20th century and the Civil Rights activists of the 50s and 60s so that
women and blacks could secure the right to vote, it makes me very sad that so
many people today have come to view voting as pointless.
I do understand why. Our
governments – locally, statewide and federally – have become completely
co-opted by Big Money: corporations, lobbyists for various industries, and rich
individuals, whose only concerns are maintaining and furthering their own
interests. In both houses of Congress, the vast majority of Representatives and
Senators are (1) male, (2) white and (3) millionaires, multi-millionaires and a
few billionaires. Their concern seems to be getting elected (and re-elected) to
their cushy jobs with good salaries (everyone needs pin money), extraordinary
benefits & perks, and very brief actual-work periods.
The Republicans, once a
stodgy party interested primarily in minimal government spending and low taxes
for the upper middle class and rich (when rich wasn’t yet obscenely über
wealthy), has moved so far to the Lunatic Fringe Right and Ultra Conservative
that they have zero concern for
anybody’s human rights, civil rights, health & well-being, education, or
anything else that should accompany citizenship for all citizens. In the name
of Christianity (which shouldn’t even be in the picture!), they’ve decided that
they and they alone hold the moral high ground on every conceivable issue. And
ever since the election of America’s first black President, all that has been
transparent is their racism and determination to prevent him from functioning –
and they’ve made a good job of it!
But perhaps even more
disappointing are the Democrats. We know who and what the Republicans are. But
who and what are the Democrats? They’re disconnected from each other; generally
cowardly when it comes to speaking to and acting against any sort of
formidable, oppositional power; they have been unsupportive of their own
President; and as a result of all this, have failed utterly to combat the 1% on
behalf of the rest of us. They appear to be a bit more willing and able to rise
to the occasion for this critical mid-term election and the endless campaign
for the 2016 Presidency that will immediately follow, but still, it is indeed
hard to work up a whole lot of enthusiasm for them.
If you don’t want to render President Obama completely impotent for the next two years, the Democrats, for all their weaknesses, must NOT lose control of the Senate. There are opportunities nationwide to get rid of some entrenched Republican Congressional representatives or avoid new ones. There are critical Governorships and State Senatorial races. There are important Propositions on the ballots of many states. There is an opportunity tomorrow to show by our numbers that we’re here and we do care about the governments we have. We may not be able to make great strides this time around, but we can rattle the status quo – perhaps just enough to enlarge Democratic balls and impact for 2016. Don’t give up yet. Please vote tomorrow and give what’s left of American democracy a fighting chance.
Posted by MizB at 4:22 PM 0 comments
Saturday, July 05, 2014
A Complicated Independence Day
I slept through much of
the day – and evening – of July 4th. I had no plans and it
had been an exhausting week of shocking events (the Hobby Lobby decision, the
hateful demonstration against three busloads of frightened, stranded, children) that made me question (hardly for the first time!) what it is
that we continue to celebrate every Fourth of July. During
the few hours I was awake, I asked myself if I loved my country, if I even liked my country, and I couldn’t respond
with a clear yes or no. That freaked me out.
My mother’s parents were
both Jews who, when they were still very young, emigrated from Eastern Europe
in the years before World War I (that’s 1 not 2). They didn’t come together,
they met here. They became citizens and my grandfather served in the First
World War. My father, and his father before him, came here from the West
Indies. They too became citizens. I don’t know what my grandfather did except
work for the Chunky Candy factory in Brooklyn for all of his working life in
the U.S. For the record, they all came here legally.
My father worked as a
Merchant Marine from the time he was a teenager and during part of that career he served for the U.S. in
WWII and barely escaped from fires on two oil tankers. Later, he was a waiter
and wine steward on several trans-Atlantic ocean liners, including the S.S.
America and S.S. United States. During his many years at sea he saw a great
deal of the world.
When my mother insisted he
get a job on land and not be away from home for great lengths of time, he
became a skycap for TWA. He schlepped luggage for 25 years, but the job gave my
parents cheap-sometimes-free flying for a lot of international vacation travel.
So when my father told me, several times from my teens into adulthood, that
despite all its problems America was the greatest country in the world, I had
to at least in part believe that, because I couldn’t deny his intelligence or
experience.
Studying history was one of my father's hobbies; he knew 150 million Native Americans had been killed in the process of creating America and he didn't negate that any more than Slavery. But he also knew that history was riddled with powerful nations taking over less powerful ones and killing or enslaving the indigenous people or anyone who objected. He grew up in the British West Indies. He understood the violent, dishonorable food chain of nation-building. Yet he still loved America as it was and all it had the capacity to become.
But my parents didn’t live
to see the 21st century. They didn’t live through the terrorist
attacks of 9/11 and watch that experience make the country frightened, angry,
and hostile ever since. They didn't see new communications and manufacturing technology change everything. They didn't see our environmental destruction and indifference start to come home to roost. They didn’t see the Republicans, a fraternity of stodgy
businessmen, turn into a hateful Party committed to reversing civil, voting,
and women’s rights.
They didn’t endure the Great Recession of 2008 that nearly
tanked this country and has left us still sorely damaged. They didn’t see the
national Legislature become deliberately obstructionist in response to the
first Black US president, adding constant racist insult to political injury
from Day One. They didn’t live through this country’s two longest, incredibly
expensive, and ultimately pointless wars.
And my family of
immigrants didn’t watch this nation of immigrants despise immigrants
because they had sneaked in rather than wait their legal turn, the nation’s
hatred even extending to those who came here as little kids or who now
are escaping to here on their own as
young children, because life in their countries has become too horrible and
dangerous to endure.
My mother, who had several serious ailments and skimped on her meds because they were so expensive, didn’t live to see something resembling universal coverage be denigrated and sabotaged by politicians who feared it more than disease.
To be honest, part of what saddened me yesterday was that I didn’t have a cookout to attend or anyone with whom I could go watch the fireworks (I love fireworks), even though I dislike and disapprove of the way we’ve turned every national holiday of social and historical importance into an occasion to party and shop.
But mostly, I was and still am preoccupied with how America has stepped back. I’m angry with the Supreme Court and Congress; I’m concerned that it took our smart, idealistic President six years to realize those shitheads in Washington are never going to work with him; and I’m very worried that this year’s elections will bring even more irresponsible nutjobs into national power and give “lame duck” terrible new meaning for the next two years. Papa, I wish you were here.
Posted by MizB at 7:58 AM 0 comments
Tuesday, July 01, 2014
Twisted Justice
Yesterday, when America’s
Supreme Court once again decided 5-to-4, this time in favor of Hobby
Lobby/Conestoga Wood, they asserted that the religious beliefs of the owners of
private corporations trump the individual beliefs and rights of their
employees. This decision does much more than deprive women of insurance coverage
for certain kinds of contraception. It gives seriously discomfiting credence to
the ridiculous notion that corporations are people and that the rights of
corporate persons are greater than the rights of human persons – which is
pretty much how things have been going in all areas for some time.
So the Court ended its
session with yet another attempt to further a Conservative Christian agenda,
redefine personhood, set a dangerous precedent, and create genuine confusion
about what is legal, let alone Constitutional. It’s no wonder that Justice
Bader Ginsberg in her dissent said, “The court, I fear, has ventured into a
minefield.”
I’m so angry about this
latest SCOTUS bullshit that I am literally physically, emotionally, and
mentally drained. And the thought that I’m morally obliged to help fight this
is thoroughly overwhelming – in large part because I don’t understand it.
According to the research
I’ve done, the Constitution, in the First and Fourteenth Amendments, makes
clear the necessity for a separation of Church and State, even though that
specific language isn’t used. But it doesn’t address a unification of Church and
Commerce. So what in the Constitution
makes it legal for the owners of a private company to determine what kinds of
health insurance coverage they will or won’t provide to their employees, not
based on cost or law, but on the company’s owners religious beliefs?
Hobby Lobby is a very big
company, which is what makes it a corporation. It has thousands of employees in
hundreds of stores across the country. This is not a new business, so employees
had health insurance in the past. Apparently, it’s the provisions of
Obamacare-governed insurance that added types of contraception – such as the
Morning After pill and IUDs, methods that can induce abortion – that the deeply
anti-abortion Green family (the owners) object to and therefore don’t want to include or pay for (they don’t object to
other forms of birth control, such as the pill or diaphragms, which they are
willing to pay for – thank you, Green family…).
Let’s say, for the sake of
argument, that corporations are
people. Why do they have rights that human people don’t have? For example, I
have Medicare and pay over $100 a month for it. Medicare covers many things
that I will never need, such as medications, treatments, and surgeries that
only apply to men. Medicare doesn’t cover dental care or eye glasses or hearing
aids – all of which I do need.
Yet I can’t say “I don’t
want to pay for men’s stuff, I want my
Medicare payments to cover what I
need.” If the Green family gets to cherry pick the coverage they will and won’t
cover – not just for themselves but for thousands of other people – based on
what they believe, why can’t I do the
same, just for myself, based on what I actually need?
It would be bad enough if
it stopped there. But as Justice Bader Ginsberg also pointed out, “Would the
exemption…extend to employers with religiously grounded objections to blood
transfusions (Jehovah’s Witnesses); antidepressants (Scientologists);
medications derived from pigs, including anesthesia, intravenous fluids, and
pills coated with gelatin (certain Muslims, Jews, and Hindus); and
vaccinations[?]…Not much help there for the lower courts bound by today’s decision.”
This, my friends, is what’s known as a truly
slippery slope. All of America, I fear, has ventured into a minefield.
Posted by MizB at 5:01 AM 0 comments
Monday, June 02, 2014
Why?
In 1995, during my
freelance writing career, I interviewed Jim Lehrer of the PBS NewsHour when Robert MacNeil, his co-anchor of 22 years,
retired, and Lehrer was preparing to staff the anchor desk alone. A seasoned
newspaper reporter when the two had first teamed up to cover the 1973 Watergate
hearings, Lehrer said he had still learned a lot from MacNeil, citing as an
example that the most valuable follow-up question he could ask an interview
subject was “Why?” I found that wonderfully simple, sage and clearly important.
I used it often in my own subsequent interviews, always with valuable results,
because it took the subject off-guard and “off-script.” To this day I listen
for it in on-air news interviews and am sorry to note that I rarely hear it – especially
when it really needs to be asked!
Last week, Daily
Kos reported on a survey of America’s oft-mentioned “one percent,” the
country’s very richest and most politically powerful people. It asked if they favored
such things as: more U.S. companies operating
overseas (75%); the federal government providing jobs for all who are willing
to work but can’t find jobs in the private sector (8%); cutting Medicare,
education, and highways [repair] to reduce the federal deficit (58%); federal
spending to ensure good public schools for all (35%); federal government
support to ensure college for all who want it (28%); redistribution of wealth through heavy taxes
on the rich (17%); cutting Social Security (33%); and believing it is the
federal government’s responsibility to reduce income inequality (13%).
The figures are revealing
and discouraging – less in comparison with the general public (who score a high,
sharp opposite in this survey) but more in comparison to the
famous robber barons of the early 20th century. Generally speaking,
today’s rich don’t have their sense of noblesse
oblige, of a special responsibility to help society in general and the poor
in particular. The survey provided the numbers, but it didn’t ask why people who have so much begrudge
others anything, everything?
I have a sense of the why. In the
1970s, I spent four years working for a “society” charity and had occasion to
deal with a lot of very rich people. When “in their cups,” as they usually were
by the end of a long charity event, they were often childlike and perceivably
sad. I had odd, intimate (not sexual, but close, personal, unguarded)
experiences with a number of them when they were drunk. When they were sober
and their defenses were up, many were hard, rude and haughty.
I think that rather than
being oblivious to the rest of the country, they know very well that they have
more than they deserve – even if they’ve worked for it, rather than inherited
it; “need,” real need, doesn’t enter into the conversation. From their
perspective they do need every cent they have and they do deserve it and
they’re entitled to it because they’re
just better people.
It’s no accident that
government benefits are now called “entitlements.” That term is sarcastic and intended to make the rest of us feel worthless and nervy for
asking for anything. They don’t believe that ordinary folks, let alone the
poor, are entitled to anything; if we
were, we would already have it! And it’s certainly not the responsibility of
the rich to give it to us, either personally, or via that blood-sucking,
tax-imposing albatross around their gilded necks called government.
The charity I worked for
was an employment agency for the disabled. We touted the dignity of
work (which is very real) and the
rich who supported us loved that. When some of them came to our offices,
they delighted in seeing our own disabled staff members, people who were
missing limbs, or riding in wheel chairs, or trembling with cerebral palsy
working to help others like themselves get jobs. The rich like
charities for people whose problems “aren’t their own fault,” like the disabled
and babies with cancer. But philanthropic giving is way down from what it was back in the
70s – especially for ordinary people with aspirational goals, or poor people
trying to get on their feet. Money – and compassion – are hard to come by these
days.
Of course there are some
rich people who are kind and generous and care about their fellow humans; who
are also smart enough to realize that living in a country which is increasingly
poor, ignorant, and falling apart is not in their own best interest. But for
the most part, the rich care about themselves and they don’t like or care about
us. That’s the why. The next
follow-up question is: What are we going to do about it?
Posted by MizB at 3:51 PM 0 comments
Thursday, May 22, 2014
Class Warfare 2
I got two emails about my first post on the need to fight back hard against
the class warfare being waged by the Right. One came from a Conservative friend
who is by no means a rich man but is very, very concerned about the economy and
our national debt and deficit, and believes that if you push the rich too hard
they’ll go away, and jobs and the very underpinnings of our economy will
disappear. It seemed that all he got from that post was that I was advocating
for higher taxes on the rich. The other came from a Liberal friend who said he
and his wife had been politically active for decades, often to no avail and
frequently suffering harsh and ridiculous response from within the ranks, which
is why he’s now a burnt-out recluse and won’t do much anymore.
While I am all for
increasing taxes on the rich (not the 80%-90% it was during the
Eisenhower years, but a healthy 30% they can’t avoid through tax loopholes,
hiding their money offshore, or special privilege), higher taxes on the rich wasn’t all I had in mind. And, I too
was more politically active for decades than I am now, and learned that victories
are often minimal and your “friends” can be really annoying, short-sighted,
easily distracted, rigid and hostile. Trying to organize the Left is like
trying to corral a bunch of smart kids suffering from ADD wandering around a large room.
So let me get to the guts of this hopefully more explanatory post by saying this: class warfare – which, ironically, the rich usually accuse the poor of initiating with their commie-inspired protests and other carrying on – is not just about money. It’s about a combination of economic fairness, social justice, how we view each other, and how we view the role and responsibility of government. We, the 97% who are struggling, for the most part see things differently than do the 3% who are very rich. Politically, the 97% isn’t united. What we have in common is that we’re all having a very hard time – a situation created by the 3%. Which is why, God help us, we have to try to get together and push back.
Now nearly every member of Congress and the Senate is a millionaire to one degree or another, and both bodies are largely white and male, all of which makes it difficult for them to understand the plights of ordinary people. Add to this the impact of the demented Tea Party, whose original concerns were economic (like my Conservative friend), but which came to include social issues over time with positions based in Christian Fundamentalism. Their strident über conservatism completed the co-opting of the Republican party that began when the sanctified Ronald Reagan said our national problems weren’t about dysfunction in government, the problem was government itself. Then Wall Street collapsed and America elected a Black president who intended to use progressive approaches to financial and social issues and all hell broke loose.
When the people who run government don’t believe in government, government doesn’t run well. When government is run by people with money, privilege and power, government will not make policy that creates/provides economic fairness and social justice. When you throw religious ideas into the mix, which have no place in government to begin with, you end up with wildly unbalanced economics, a huge lack of social justice, and very twisted views of one another and the role and responsibility of government. In other words, you end up where we are now.
The Right is telling us that the rich are job creators and the poor have brought their problems on themselves, neither of which is true. They also tell us that unrestricted free-market capitalism is the best and only way to go, which it isn’t. They say it isn’t government’s responsibility to help us, which it is. And their primary goal is to generate profit from everything and to maintain a massively expensive and totally unexamined system of military defense, which is insane. They say government should be small, when what it should be is efficient, regardless of its size.
They say government should not intrude into people’s personal lives, except when it comes to women having control over their own bodies and people having the right to love and marry who they choose, even if they’re of the same sex. They say racism no longer exists, which is a lie; that science is wrong about everything, which is religion talking; and that government can’t afford to pay for things like healthcare, social services, education, infrastructure repair, or to fight poverty and hunger – all of which is precisely what government should spend its money on.
The Left is speaking out against all this, but not very loudly and not in a unified voice. Which is why government is getting nowhere – or moving in the exactly opposite and wrong direction – when it comes to major reforms in tax policy, immigration, unemployment/job creation, the role of money in electoral politics, voter suppression, gun policy, economic gender inequities, environmental protection, the better understanding and use of new technology, creative and enlightened foreign policy, prison policy, drug policy, and all the other things mentioned in the paragraph above. These are the reasons we’re already engaged in class warfare and why we have to fight back harder and better. Nothing less than our survival – individually, as a people, and as a country – is at stake. I hope I’ve made my argument clearer.
So let me get to the guts of this hopefully more explanatory post by saying this: class warfare – which, ironically, the rich usually accuse the poor of initiating with their commie-inspired protests and other carrying on – is not just about money. It’s about a combination of economic fairness, social justice, how we view each other, and how we view the role and responsibility of government. We, the 97% who are struggling, for the most part see things differently than do the 3% who are very rich. Politically, the 97% isn’t united. What we have in common is that we’re all having a very hard time – a situation created by the 3%. Which is why, God help us, we have to try to get together and push back.
Now nearly every member of Congress and the Senate is a millionaire to one degree or another, and both bodies are largely white and male, all of which makes it difficult for them to understand the plights of ordinary people. Add to this the impact of the demented Tea Party, whose original concerns were economic (like my Conservative friend), but which came to include social issues over time with positions based in Christian Fundamentalism. Their strident über conservatism completed the co-opting of the Republican party that began when the sanctified Ronald Reagan said our national problems weren’t about dysfunction in government, the problem was government itself. Then Wall Street collapsed and America elected a Black president who intended to use progressive approaches to financial and social issues and all hell broke loose.
When the people who run government don’t believe in government, government doesn’t run well. When government is run by people with money, privilege and power, government will not make policy that creates/provides economic fairness and social justice. When you throw religious ideas into the mix, which have no place in government to begin with, you end up with wildly unbalanced economics, a huge lack of social justice, and very twisted views of one another and the role and responsibility of government. In other words, you end up where we are now.
The Right is telling us that the rich are job creators and the poor have brought their problems on themselves, neither of which is true. They also tell us that unrestricted free-market capitalism is the best and only way to go, which it isn’t. They say it isn’t government’s responsibility to help us, which it is. And their primary goal is to generate profit from everything and to maintain a massively expensive and totally unexamined system of military defense, which is insane. They say government should be small, when what it should be is efficient, regardless of its size.
They say government should not intrude into people’s personal lives, except when it comes to women having control over their own bodies and people having the right to love and marry who they choose, even if they’re of the same sex. They say racism no longer exists, which is a lie; that science is wrong about everything, which is religion talking; and that government can’t afford to pay for things like healthcare, social services, education, infrastructure repair, or to fight poverty and hunger – all of which is precisely what government should spend its money on.
The Left is speaking out against all this, but not very loudly and not in a unified voice. Which is why government is getting nowhere – or moving in the exactly opposite and wrong direction – when it comes to major reforms in tax policy, immigration, unemployment/job creation, the role of money in electoral politics, voter suppression, gun policy, economic gender inequities, environmental protection, the better understanding and use of new technology, creative and enlightened foreign policy, prison policy, drug policy, and all the other things mentioned in the paragraph above. These are the reasons we’re already engaged in class warfare and why we have to fight back harder and better. Nothing less than our survival – individually, as a people, and as a country – is at stake. I hope I’ve made my argument clearer.
Posted by MizB at 2:00 AM 1 comments
Monday, May 19, 2014
The Right Has Started Class Warfare. It’s Time for the Left to Fight Back
Income inequality – a
polite term for the rich squeezing the guts out of everyone else – is a hot-button issue that frightens the rich (who are obsessed with keeping and enlarging their wealth) and so far immobilizing the
rest of us, probably because the rich are united and, uh, very well-funded, and we’re all struggling to
survive and focusing on our personal pet issues.
We have income
inequality that surpasses the Gilded Age of the early 20th century
“robber barons” because the [largely] well-heeled Right has
been waging genuine
class warfare and we haven’t been fighting back. The working class and
[what’s left of] the middle class have been duped into hating the poor, as if the poor are the problem (!) and
not seeing that our personal pet issues, be they unemployment, racial civil
rights, gay rights, women’s rights, human rights/modern slavery, animal rights,
immigration, the environment, climate change/science acceptance, energy policy,
education, foreign policy, the social safety net, are all connected by money and politics. And as you may have
noticed, the rich are in control of money and politics and we have foolishly
allowed ourselves to be fucked over by classic divide-and-conquer tactics. We
have to shape up, join hands (whatever our differences may be) and fight back.
The first part of our
battle must be to wrestle political power back from the Wealthy Right. We can’t
afford to be politically jaded or disengaged because even if politics is
corrupt bullshit, it does matter who
gets elected. The Rich Right understands this. Recent, new, and more-sure-to-come
voter ID laws, as well as the gerrymandering of Congressional districts, are
clearly a Republican/ Conservative effort to block the voting path of the young,
the old, and racial “minorities,” all of whom tend to vote for Democratic
candidates. They have created the myth of voter fraud to justify these actions,
but it's nothing less than a direct assault on the democratic process and a key
weapon in the Right’s class war. And as the saying goes: “It isn’t true class warfare until we fight back.”
It’s also important to
remember that part of this class warfare is where and how we live and how we’re
treated. I live (born and raised) in New York City, once the most sophisticated
city in America with a cultural heart, intellectual brain, bohemian flair and
thousands of neighborhoods filled with privately-owned shops and restaurants.
We had a diversified population comprised of the poor, working class, middle
class, and the rich. Over the past 30 years, New York has been castrated into
something resembling a mid-Western Disneyland Nowhere that has gentrified the
poor out of town to God knows where (well, they’re still working on that), and combined
the working and middle classes into a hostile heap hanging by its fingernails
and cow towing to the rich like the little demigods they are.
As an example, you need
look no further than housing in Manhattan and Brooklyn (the other
three boroughs are in the midst of being similarly transformed). Besides being
outrageously expensive, housing is increasingly segregated by class. The obscenely wealthy real estate developers
of new rental buildings get tax credits if a portion of the property is devoted
to “affordable housing.” It is – but many of these new buildings have separate
entrances, lobbies, and levels of security for the “affordable” tenants and the
“market rate” tenants. If there are “luxury” amenities in the building, such as
gyms, spas, roof gardens, children’s play areas, even storage spaces, the “affordables” are not permitted access
to them! No contact with the “trash” required.
What makes this
particularly infuriating is that, according to a recent article in the New
York Times, the average annual income of the “affordables” is $51,010
(we’re not talking candidates for public housing projects here) vs. $103,680
for the market-rate folks. And, on average, the “affordable” cost of a
one-bedroom apartment is $1,321 a month, compared with $2,696 at the market-rate.
Yes, New York is particularly expensive. But rents nationwide are high and
getting higher, especially in big cities – but not exclusively. I’ve lived in
my apartment for 36 years and without going into specifics, suffice it to say
I’m blessed to be in a co-op building that’s part of a special pricing program
that dates back to the 1960s. But this status will change in a few years and
I’m likely to end up being a renter in the same apartment I currently own.
Anyone who isn’t filthy rich and sides with the Right is delusional
and not thinking in his/her best interest. Economically,
the Right are giants; socially they’re dinosaurs. They’re not your friends. I
don’t mind that there are rich people. America needs millionaires. But
multi-multi-millionaires and billionaires (and multi-multi-billionaires),
especially when they make laws, conduct business and cut social services, showing no concern for anyone except others like themselves?
Posted by MizB at 1:59 AM 0 comments
Friday, April 11, 2014
The Surreality of Now
April has always been a
melancholy month for me, but this year
the craziness of the present has overcome the wistfulness of the past, because some
of the social and political events going on have left me laughing and crying at
the same time.
Let’s start with a little
item out of Pakistan. A nine-month old baby was officially charged with attempted
murder, because he, along with his father and grandfather, were part of “…a mob protesting against gas cuts and price
increases [that] stoned police and gas company workers trying to collect
overdue bills…” according to an NBC
News affiliate. As pictured above, the baby cried while being
finger-printed; later tried to play with reporters’ microphones while the media
interviewed his father; and is now in hiding in an undisclosed location. My
favorite line was that this incident “…has
thrown a spotlight on Pakistan's dysfunctional criminal justice system.” Yeah.
And these people have the bomb…
There have been several
recent articles about the growing increase in sexual desire and activity among
the aging and elderly – which has resulted in an increase in STDs, but also hope
for folks in their 60s (like me) and 70s and 80s, too. But my favorite story on
this phenomenon came from a CBS
News affiliate about a nursing home in West Babylon, NY, that was being
sued by the son of one of the residents after a male stripper performed there. “A 16-member resident committee had
requested the September 2012 performance and the nursing home paid the $250
fee,” explained an attorney for the home. This is a picture of one of the
old ladies stuffing money into the stripper’s briefs:
I could show you a photo
of the U.S. Supreme Court, but why bother? You know what that
5-to-4-Right-leaning-crowd looks like. What I can’t show you is what’s been
going on in their heads lately. Their most recent decision on money in
politics, McCutcheon Et Al vs. Federal Election Commission, on top of the
previous Citizens United decision, as well as their gouging out a core portion
of the 49-year-old Voting Rights Act, breaks my heart and blows my mind.
How
can these people (the five Conservatives) truly believe that allowing more
money into the already overpriced and corrupted political process is a good
idea – or harmless at worst? After the blatant and still ongoing efforts in
many states to make it harder to vote for young and old people and people
of color, how can they think that any
portion of the Voting Rights Act has become obsolete? I know that none of the
justices is stupid. So what am I, or any American, to think: that they’re
uninformed, or racist, or mean, or on the take? If the top court of the land is
fucked up, where do we go from here?
I’ll tell you where: from
Democracy to Oligarchy. If for some reason you don’t know what that is, it’s a
form of government in which all power rests in the hands of a small group or
class…like, say, the very, very rich and their friends: the very rich and the
plain old rich. And the first order of business of an Oligarchy is to suppress
the will (and possibly existence) of the vast majority that isn’t them. The
second task is to make sure that the different members of that majority see
each other as the enemy, the problem, rather than join forces against the tiny
minority with all the money and power. The third task is to make day-to-day
survival so difficult for the vast majority that they focus the rest of their
time just trying to put food on the table. It also helps to do things like gut
social programs as deeply as possible, keep basic education mediocre and higher
education unaffordable, and turn your own religious beliefs into laws, so that
people are more concerned with being sinners than citizens (that only partially
works).
And whatever you do, make
it harder for people to laugh – because as all survivors know, laughter makes
fighting the good fight easier.
Posted by MizB at 6:33 AM 0 comments
Sunday, February 02, 2014
Welcome Back to Black History Month
It’s February in America –
which means it’s Black History Month, a tradition that began in 1926 with
“Negro History Week,” initiated by the
Association for the Study of Negro Life and History. It became Black History Month in 1976 in conjunction with the celebration of the U.S.
Bicentennial and the urging of then-President Gerald Ford. It may surprise you to know that this occasion
is also celebrated in the U.K. (starting in 1987) and Canada (as of 1995),
because there are a lot of Black people in those countries, too, primarily
(originally) from Africa and the West Indies.
In recent years, some Black
Americans have taken to calling it African-American History Month. This irritates me, because I have never liked
the term, since most Black Americans know very little about the 54 countries on
the planet’s second-largest and second-most-populous continent. In addition, many Africans feel no sense of
connection to American Blacks or even consider them to be Black, due to more than 200 years of interracial hanky-panky
(both lovingly consensual and viciously imposed).
Other Black Americans have
started to resist, even outright object to, Black History Month, because they
see in what is meant to be a positive acknowledgment of long-ignored history,
an unpleasant continuation of the separation of Blacks and Whites in the full
picture of American history. I myself
fall into this category – sort of. For
one thing, so many people, events and milestone accomplishments are routinely
left out of the telling of Black history – during this designated month and in
general education.
For another, if the
widespread disrespect shown to America’s first Black President by both houses
of Congress – indeed, the idea that he is not a legitimate President – is anything to go by, a new, more
sophisticated racism is still very much with us and Black History Month does
absolutely nothing to diminish that. (I’m
sure there are people who dislike Barack Obama because of what they perceive as
his bad policies and ideas and nothing more.
But the ballyhoo about his birthplace, his college records and his
religion demonstrates that there are a great many legislators and citizens who simply can’t abide the
idea of a Black man in the White House.)
Last but not least, nearly
40 years of Black History Month has done very little to educate American Blacks
about the fulsomeness of their own heritage – and virtually nothing to
demonstrate to White Americans that Black history is an integral part of
American history overall. The young
generations of Americans, Black and White, may be more accepting of each other
than their elders – but they are still greatly uninformed about their country’s
history, period.
So, what is the
“appropriate” way to handle Black History Month: ignore it; celebrate it joyously
no matter who does or doesn’t participate; or use it as an opportunity to
expand the boundaries of American history at every level of education? I don’t know what the answer is. All I know is that we’re still a long way
from having a complete and unified understanding of who and what we were and
what we are as a nation, and that is a very dangerous and unhealthy state of
affairs.
Posted by MizB at 9:11 AM 0 comments
Tuesday, January 28, 2014
So Long, It's Been Good to Know Ya
PETE SEEGER died yesterday. I feel as if I've lost a beloved friend, a favorite relative; certainly a guiding light. The following is a comment I left on The New York Times among the hundreds of others that follow their excellent obituary. (It's also a Times Pick, should you want to find it in the paper.)
I really don't have much else to say right now...
Pete Seeger was and will always be one of [the few] great heroes of my life. His music was an inspiration, particularly because his life was an ongoing testament to principle, commitment, and an unwavering belief that personal action, especially in concert with others of like mind, can effect enormous positive social change.
He was a unique tower and shimmering beacon of progressive light. But he was also a man with a private heart. When his wife Toshi died last year, I knew Pete wouldn't be far behind.
One of the proudest moments of my life came in 1994 when Mr. Seeger was among those receiving The Kennedy Center Honor and I was on the outside public relations team promoting the event. It gave me the opportunity to interview him by phone and not only did he speak freely and candidly, he spoke to me as if I were an old friend and even sang two songs to me. We were on the phone for half an hour!
May the great yet humble Pete Seeger rest in peace and live on in spirit. And may his death motivate the rest of us to re-examine our values and re-kindle our activism.
I really don't have much else to say right now...
Pete Seeger was and will always be one of [the few] great heroes of my life. His music was an inspiration, particularly because his life was an ongoing testament to principle, commitment, and an unwavering belief that personal action, especially in concert with others of like mind, can effect enormous positive social change.
He was a unique tower and shimmering beacon of progressive light. But he was also a man with a private heart. When his wife Toshi died last year, I knew Pete wouldn't be far behind.
One of the proudest moments of my life came in 1994 when Mr. Seeger was among those receiving The Kennedy Center Honor and I was on the outside public relations team promoting the event. It gave me the opportunity to interview him by phone and not only did he speak freely and candidly, he spoke to me as if I were an old friend and even sang two songs to me. We were on the phone for half an hour!
May the great yet humble Pete Seeger rest in peace and live on in spirit. And may his death motivate the rest of us to re-examine our values and re-kindle our activism.
Posted by MizB at 9:49 AM 3 comments
Friday, December 14, 2012
The Tower is Closing
For the past couple of
months, I’ve been weighing the pros and cons of ending this blog, which I
started in August, 2007. In the end,
I’ve decided the pros outweigh the cons – so this is my final post.
This blog has given me a
chance to express my ideas, concerns and opinions and giving up this
opportunity was a big “con” in my consideration. However, I’ve never done the enormous amount
of personal and technical work necessary to bring this blog to the attention of
a larger audience, and I don’t feel like doing it now. But by not doing it, I’ve increasingly felt
that I’ve just been sporadically and inconsistently screaming into an unhearing
void, and what’s the point in continuing if I’m not going to do the work to
promote/market Views From the Tower? For me, the final answer is that there is no
point, so it’s time to end it.
That said, I very much
appreciate that those of you who have been following this blog took the time to
do so, and some of you have often taken the time to send me private emails of
response: much praise and sometimes disagreement. All of it was gratifying, encouraging, and
gave me the sense that I wasn’t entirely screaming into an unhearing void. Thank you very, very much.
As a writer, I certainly
intend to keep writing. I’m working on a
mystery novel, something I’ve always wanted to do. In a way, given my politics, it amuses me and
reminds me of the time in the 70s that Eldridge Cleaver moved to Paris and
became a pants designer. But I’m no
Eldridge Cleaver and also have no delusion that I’ll become a modern Agatha
Christie. I just want to have some fun
(and maybe make a little money). I
haven’t had a lot of fun as a writer and now seems like a good time to do it. Equally important, I abandoned my relationship
with The Tarot about ten years ago and I want to reclaim it. It enriched my life when I had it and I want
that connection again – and that’s a study/practice that takes time. You may or may not understand what this
means, but suffice it to say The Tarot is important to me and that’s reason
enough for me.
In general, having turned
60 earlier this year, I’ve been giving a lot of thought to time – time past,
present and future. And December is
annually the month in which I give the most thought to time: it’s filled with
holidays I no longer celebrate with family and friends; it’s the end of one
year and the birth of a new one; and I’m reminded of what was lost in Decembers
past. John Lennon, who was murdered at
the age of 40 in December 1980, would have been 72 this year. His five-year-old son who was left fatherless
turned 37. A dear friend of mine, Stuart
Franklin, died in December 21 years ago.
Had my mother and father survived their 70s, they would be 89 and 90 now
– a misery I’m glad they were spared, but I still miss them terribly.
I also think about the
meaningful, functional time I have left.
I don’t have oodles of it. Over
the past few months, arthritis has settled in my left shoulder, wrist and hand. Over the past few years, my teeth have
started screwing up. My right knee is
prone to slipping out from under me. My
hearing, especially in my left ear, has greatly diminished. My home and daily routine are both a mess and
hugely dysfunctional. I need the time to
get these things together and bring some peace and order to the rest of my time.
So again, my thanks, and
my best wishes to all of you, as well as my hope that you have the opportunity
to do what you wish and need to do with your time. Also, Happy Holidays and Happy New Year. Here’s hoping the future brings better times
for us all.
Posted by MizB at 12:32 AM 2 comments
Friday, November 09, 2012
Good News…Bad News
I was, of course,
delighted and relieved that President Obama was re-elected and the
Democrats maintain the majority in the Senate.
I’m wary but hopeful that Republicans, at least some, recognize the
major changes in American demographics and attitudes and understand that if
their party is to remain viable, they have no choice but to reject the
far-right-as-you-can-go fringe and move more to a workable center in order to
actually help run the country – which they can now do, since they failed to achieve their primary objective: making Barack Obama a
one-term president. I was also very
pleased that both marriage equality and the decriminalization of marijuana made
strides in a few states. All of this is
good news.
But, now that the nation
has managed to suffer through this seemingly-endless campaign, there is a
considerable amount of bad news to contemplate and correct – and some of it isn’t “news,” just
situations, some fairly recent and others that have been with us for quite a
long time.
Let’s begin with the
length and cost of this election: two years and $4.2 billion. The rest of the
Democratic World (yes, Virginia, there are over 170 democratic countries) manage to hold elections in just six months to a year. Why can’t we?
They also manage to not spend billions of dollars or euros or whatever
currency they use, and the funds raised aren’t largely comprised of “dark
money” (unidentified individual and corporate donors) in massive Super Pacs. These two situations alone hugely undermine
the truth/reality of our democracy, let alone its ability to function. The
fact that more than half the country didn’t vote at all is directly tied to
these two factors.
The lack of voting can
also be attributed to political cynicism and fatigue on the part of the
citizenry; the inability of the two parties to agree on facts – which are different from opinions and perceived solutions
to problems big and small; the willingness of both parties to fight dirty and outright
lie; the hugely disparate methods of voting, from registration to voting to
counting the votes; the outrageously blatant voter suppression that went on
during this election cycle; the distinction of “important, battleground states”
that make many people in and outside those states feel that their votes are
meaningless; and, most of all, the existence of the long-outmoded Electoral
College. These issues pose a valid
question: given these factors, why should anyone feel obliged to take an active
interest in politics, let alone leave the comfort of home to go out and vote?
Last but most assuredly
not least is the media – from daily television news coverage to the “debates”
to coverage of the results on Election Day.
Let me take these issues in reverse order.
When I was a kid and then
a young voter, there was such a thing as “No electioneering near the
polls.” You couldn’t even enter a voting
station wearing a political button. Then,
the three major broadcast TV networks (which was all we had) didn’t begin
coverage of the results until the West Coast had largely closed its polls. These practices were designed to not
influence voters on Election Day itself and they were sacrosanct.
In this day and age,
however, we have 24/7 news channels: three majors (Left, Right and Center) and
a few minors. Their Election Day
coverage began at the crack of dawn on Tuesday, which amounts to electronic
electioneering near the polls. This
isn’t good; this isn’t right. We also have legitimate news sources as well
as blogs and social media on the (relatively) new-fangled Internet, which
operates on its own 24/7 spectrum in the space-time continuum and is governed
and controlled by nothing and nobody.
Sounds great in theory, but a lot of Internet power is in the hands of
irresponsible, disreputable and self-serving persons and groups. What can be done about this? Lastly, we have polls and pundits. Polls and pundits are nothing new, but we now
have a monumental number of them, some of them credible, others not. Combined, they contribute to the divisiveness
and dullness of political information, not to mention a serious blurring of
factual news and both informed and uninformed opinion.
As a result of all this,
we have daily news coverage that can frequently rot the brain the way sugar
causes cavities. News outlets spend more
time on gaffes, scandals, taking things
out of context, and on the political
horserace than they do on major issues.
Right now, before President Obama has even been re-inaugurated, much of
the media are speculating about the horse races of 2014 and 2016. This does not help politics or elections seem
meaningful; it’s like sport for news/political junkies. I totally ignore major/minor league athletics
because they bore and annoy me. With
this kind of political coverage, why should many citizens feel differently
about politics? Then there are the
debates the media moderate and broadcast.
These might be helpful if they truly covered all the important issues of
the day. But they don’t. They’re rigid, limited and vary in format in
a way that does nothing to help bring issues to the fore. Is this any way to run a railroad?
If indeed America is to
remain a democracy and if we’re going to continue to have elections big and
small that actually mean something, then we must
(no ifs, ands or buts) reform election law from financing to process. And if we’re going to continue to have
24-hour news cycles (and that’s not likely to change) on TV and online, modern journalism
must honestly re-assess its strengths and weaknesses and how they use their
time. Currently, public television
(which those who apparently don’t watch it seem to think consists largely of
children’s programming; so not true!) and C-SPAN are the only outlets I’m aware
of that routinely produce and air a diversity of documentaries and panel
discussions on major political issues, both fiscal and social, on a regular,
ongoing basis.
So, while I’m glad my guy
won, I’m definitely not a happy
camper about the dysfunction of political contests and the media that cover
them. Once we manage to not fall off the
fiscal cliff that is currently of serious concern, I hope our leaders and our
media will make the time to examine and clean up their acts.
Posted by MizB at 5:47 AM 0 comments
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)














