MizB is a stunned, weary 20th Century woman struggling to cope with the horror and banality of the present as she reflects on the facts of the past and the unknown of the future.
Today marked the two month anniversary of the Occupy Wall Street (OWS) movement. Since it began, OWS events have sprung up in cities and towns across America – 1,000 locations in all. OWS has struck a chord among an increasing number, and an increasing diversity, of Americans in the “99%.” And how was this anniversary celebrated? With police…shall we say, “over-zealousness.”
It would appear that mayors from coast-to-coast have been on conference calls together (so says the grapevine) trying to figure out how to “handle” OWS – and have concluded that a paramilitary use of their police forces is the way to go. Sharp, progressive, creative thinking, eh?
OWS – despite its lack of a “specific” agenda, blah blah blah – has been remarkably disciplined in its commitment to non-violence, all the more remarkable because, unlike during the Civil Rights movement of the ‘60s, they have not been formally trained in non-violent tactics. Nonetheless, the original group in New York has been dispossessed from Zuccotti Park, their personal belongings confiscated, and their persons subjected to outright violence by heavily armed and shielded police. (I guess it was too cold for fire hoses and all the dogs were busy elsewhere trying to sniff out marijuana.)
Has the OWS been messy? Yes. Have they inconvenienced and interfered with the normal comings and goings of others? Yes. Have there been legitimate concerns about public health and safety? Yes. Have municipal governments done anything to positively, non-violently and economically address these issues (allowing port-o-potties, for example)? No. And what has been the result? Greater determination plus increased and more focused action by OWS. Today was a National Day of Action for OWS; from sea to shining sea they left their campsites and marched, and occupied other locations, like banks and subways.
The far-right has declared that OWS is dead, but they’ve already demonstrated considerable confusion about what constitutes life and death. Indeed, OWS is very much alive, growing, maturing, and attracting increasing participation and media attention. More than 30,000 people (including a lot of organized labor) marched in Manhattan tonight and nearly 300 were willingly arrested. I know it’s been a while since we’ve seen one, so we may not immediately recognize it – but this is the beginning of a New American Revolution.
Something else happened yesterday that is also revolutionary. Six representatives from a group of 200 very rich people known as The Patriotic Millionaires met with tax phobic troublemaker, Grover Norquist, begging him to release Republicans from their “no new taxes ever” pledge and finally increase taxes on those earning $1 million (or more) annually – acknowledging the disparity between their contributions and those of the 99%. Norquist dismissed them as “Democratic Party hacks.” They suggested that Norquist move to Somalia.
The photo above is the iconic picture that has come to define the infamous Kent State Massacre, an Anti Vietnam War protest held at Kent State University in Ohio in May, 1970. During that event, National Guardsmen responding to the “uprising” killed 4 students and wounded 9 more – and America was up in arms.
“Kent State” inspired Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young’s song Ohio, and, Buffalo Springfield’s For What It’s Worth, which was actually written in 1967 in response to the LAPD’s assault on hippies, over time has also become associated with Kent State. Currently, the song’s lyrics* have been used as a denotation for OWS. The message is simple: don’t respond to legitimate protest with military force; don’t dismiss earnest Americans as socialists/communists; don’t accuse sincere political activists of being dirty, drug-sodden, sex-crazed loonies; don’t demonize Americans demanding reasonable economic, political and social change. In short, don’t allow Fox News to shape your views about what’s happening.
* There’s somethin’ happenin’ here What it is ain’t exactly clear There’s a man with a gun over there Telling me I got to beware
I think it’s time we stop, children, what’s that sound Everybody look what’s going down…
…Paranoia strikes deep Into your life it will creep It starts when you’re always afraid You step out of line, the man come and take you away
We better stop, hey, what’s that sound Everybody look what’s going down…
This past August, Republican presidential hopeful Mitt Romney got a lot of heat for his assertion that “corporations are people, too” while speaking at an Iowa State Fair.The audience did not appreciate this millionaire’s personification of corporations; I didn't either.
Now, the idea of what constitutes personhood is coming from another familiar quarter.Some segments of the anti-choice movement – which has been trying to reverse the landmark Roe v. Wade decision that legalized abortion in 1973 – is trying to redefine personhood in their effort to re-criminalize abortion.
As reported in the New York Times on October 25th:“A constitutional amendment facing voters in Mississippi on Nov. 8, and similar initiatives brewing in half a dozen other states including Florida and Ohio, would declare a fertilized human egg to be a legal person, effectively branding abortion and some forms of birth control as murder. With this far-reaching anti-abortion strategy, the proponents of what they call personhood amendments hope to reshape the national debate.”
What makes this effort even more horrific than it seems at first glance is its attack on contraception, definitely including IUDs and morning-after pills, but potentially capable of affecting all forms of female birth control (nobody’s saying a word about condoms), as well as stem cell research – and we thought that battle had been fought and won!
In case you’re wondering (as I did for the longest time) why anti-choice proponents object to contraception, the very thing that prevents unwanted pregnancies, is this: as much as they object to abortion, they are equally opposed to what they define as “fornication,” meaning, any sex outside of marriage by both sexes whatever their age, and, engaging in recreational sex, even within marriage, rather than having sex solely for procreation.In short, they don’t just want to make abortion a crime, they want to make sex a crime.Welcome to the 21st century, where once again Puritans rule!
Interestingly, as the Times also notes: “The drive for personhood amendments has split the anti-abortion forces nationally.Some groups call it an inspired moral leap, while traditional leaders of the fight, including National Right to Life and the Roman Catholic bishops, have refused to promote it, charging that the tactic is reckless and could backfire, leading to a Supreme Court defeat that would undermine progress in carving away at Roe v. Wade.”
The two things I find most appalling about these initiatives is (1) they are based on religiousdefinitions of morality/sexually-appropriate behavior, which is completely unacceptable in a secular society, and (2) they are trying to extend the definition of personhood to include a spec of microscopic goo, which is what a fertilized egg is.In short, this is totally crazy.
However, maybe we as a society would not be poised at this ludicrous juncture if pro-choice advocates had, from Day One, been willing to face the secular moral and legal aspects of our position.In this regard, I am again motivated to quote the always-interesting Camille Paglia, who wrote on Salon.com during the 2008 campaign:
“Let’s take the issue of abortion rights, of which I am a firm supporter. As an atheist and libertarian, I believe that government must stay completely out of the sphere of personal choice. Every individual has an absolute right to control his or her body…But the pro-life position, whether or not it is based on religious orthodoxy, is more ethically highly evolved than my own tenet of unconstrained access to abortion on demand.My argument…has always been that nature has a master plan pushing every species toward procreation and that it is our right and even obligation as rational human beings to defy nature’s fascism…
“…Hence I have always frankly admitted that abortion is murder……I [also] support the death penalty for atrocious crimes (such as rape-murder or the murder of children).I have never understood the standard Democratic combo of support for abortion and yet opposition to the death penalty…
“…Not until the Democratic Party stringently reexamines its own implicit assumptions and rhetorical formulas will it be able to deal effectively with the enduring and now escalating challenge from the pro-life right wing. Because pro-choice Democrats have been arguing from cold expedience, they have thus far been unable to make an effective ethical case for the right to abortion.”
Fair enough.So, I will now attempt to make an effective ethical case for the right to abortion:
When a woman becomes pregnant, whatever the circumstances, the fetus within her is in the process of developing into a human being.But at least until the 7th month of pregnancy, that fetus is unable to survive outside the woman’s body and fully develop on its own.Therefore, while it is understood that a fetus is a living human being in development, it does not have legal, independent personhood status until birth.The unborn do not have a “right to life” that supersedes the rights of a born, autonomous woman.
While a fetus is within a woman’s body and is not capable of surviving outside of it, the fetus is an integral part of that woman’s body.As such, the woman has the right to do with her body what she sees fit, including the removal, the killing, of the fetus, thereby preventing its full gestation and birth.
While this may be distressing to some people, their distress does not alter a woman’s right to control her own body, including whether or not she becomes pregnant, and if so, whether or not she chooses to bring the pregnancy to term.
The justification for killing the fetus is the same as society’s justification for killing in self-defense, in defense of one’s family and home, in the course of war, in the course of law enforcement when necessary, and as a form of judicial punishment for heinous crime.Society recognizes that killing, however repugnant, is sometimes necessary, and a secular society recognizes a woman’s right to abortion as one of those necessities, because giving birth to a child that one does not want or is unable to care for is patently irresponsible and cruel.
Those who object to abortion on religious or other personal moral grounds should not have them, and the law should not attempt to coerce them into doing so.Similarly, those with moral objections to abortion – much as those who object to participation in war – have no moral or legal right to prevent another person’s abortion.
I’m pleased to take a welcome break from discouraging politics to tell you how much I’ve enjoyed the new documentary portrait of musician/singer-songwriter/film producer George Harrison, entitled George Harrison: Living in the Material World.It debuted on HBO this month, and if you are or ever were a Beatles fan, not to mention a Harrison fan, it’s really worth seeing.It features some familiar Beatles footage as well as Beatles material I’ve never seen, and, a lot about (and with) George individually.Directed by the indefatigable Martin Scorsese and produced by him and George’s wife of 30 years, Olivia Harrison, the film also offers interviews with her and their son, as well as an assortment of music and film notables, including old friends and family.
I must admit that after the Beatles broke up, I didn’t pay much attention to Harrison’s ongoing career (I was wrapped up in John & Yoko), nor did I realize how many popular Beatles songs were written by him, rather than the famous Lennon & McCartney duo – among them “Here Comes the Sun,” “If I Needed Someone,” “Blue Jay Way” and “Something (in the way she moves)”; I did recall “Don’t Bother Me,” “I, Me, Mine,” “While My Guitar Gently Weeps,” “Savoy Truffle” and of course, “Tax Man.”Apart from the Beatles, Harrison released numerous albums and generated such hits as “All Things Must Pass,” “Beware of Darkness,” “Wah-Wah” and “My Sweet Lord,” to mention a few.
I also forgot that it was George Harrison who produced “The Concerts for Bangladesh” – the concerts, the album, the film – which was the very first rock- star-studded event to serve a charitable cause, pre-dating “We Are The World,” Live Aid, all the other Aids, and all of Bono’s good work.
Now all this may say more about my foggy memory than George Harrison’s show biz prominence, but I also forgot that it was he who assembled The Traveling Wilburys, which began as musical fun among friends: he and Bob Dylan, Tom Petty, Roy Orbison and Jeff Lynne.I knew he had produced Monty Python’s The Life of Brian, but I didn’t know he mortgaged his house to do it, or that he formed a film company that produced other Python movies, along with an impressive list of other well-respected films.
I knew it was George Harrison who discovered Hindu spirituality for himself and turned the other Beatles onto it as well.I didn’t realize how strong a part it played in his life right up to the end, long after his band mates left it behind, or to what great extent his musical teacher, Ravi Shankar, was his spiritual teacher, as well.
Despite all I’ve written here, you’ll find much more to learn – and admire – about George Harrison, the man and the artist, in this new documentary.It’s a reminder of how much the Beatles gave us, together and individually, how much we’ve lost – and how much they left us.
I’ve been paying close attention to the Occupy Wall Street (OWS) movement since Week 2 and I have to say, as a counter-balancing relief from the babble of the current herd of Republican hopefuls, OWS is refreshing and encouraging.
What has surprised me is the number of people – mostly on the Right, but the Left and Center, too – who keep trying to dismiss (or smear) this socio-political phenomenon, because they haven’t stated clear goals, or provided a manifesto or list of demands. It’s like listening to someone blurt guttural screams for HELP! and standing aside, asking, “Yes, I understand you want assistance, but can you please clarify exactly what it is you want help for; and if you don’t mind, could you put your request in writing so that it can be studied by the proper committees?”
Talk about you-don’t-get-it!
Remember the 1976 film Network (written by Paddy Chayefsky, directed by Sidney Lumet) starring the late, great Peter Finch, Faye Dunaway and William Holden? It’s set in the 1970s, when the three major networks still ruled television, and tells the story of a grand old broadcast newsman left over from the salad days of grand old broadcast newsmen, a la Edward R. Murrow. One day, Howard Beale (played by Finch) comes to the studio to do his nightly newscast and instead he gives a sermon of desperation that is eerily pertinent to our times, even though it’s 36 years later. The following is taken directly from the script:
“I don’t have to tell you things are bad. Everybody knows things are bad. It’s a depression. Everybody’s out of work or scared of losing their job, the dollar buys a nickel’s worth, banks are going bust, shopkeepers keep a gun under the counter, punks are running wild in the streets, and there’s nobody anywhere who seems to know what to do, and there’s no end to it. We know the air’s unfit to breathe and our food is unfit to eat, and we sit and watch our tee-vees while some local newscaster tells us today we had fifteen homicides and sixty-three violent crimes, as if that’s the way it’s supposed to be. We all know things are bad. Worse than bad. They’re crazy. It’s like everything’s going crazy. So we don’t go out any more. We sit in the house, and slowly the world we live in gets smaller, and all we ask is please, at least leave us alone in our own living rooms. Let me have my toaster and my tee-vee and my hair-dryer and my steel-belted radials, and I won’t say anything, just leave us alone.
“Well, I’m not going to leave you alone. I want you to get mad – I don’t want you to riot. I don’t want you to protest. I don’t want you to write your Congressmen. Because I wouldn’t know what to tell you to write. I don’t know what to do about the depression and the inflation and the defense budget and the Russians and crime in the street. All I know is first you got to get mad. You’ve got to say: “I’m mad as hell and I’m not going to take this any more. I’m a human being, goddammit. My life has value.” So I want you to get up now. I want you to get out of your chairs and go to the window. Right now. I want you to go to the window, open it, and stick your head out and yell. I want you to yell: “I’m mad as hell and I’m not going to take this any more!” Things have got to change. But you can’t change them unless you’re mad. You have to get mad!”
That, ladies and gentlemen, is what the OWS is about. Beale’s rage against the machine and call-to-expression is one of the greatest in modern cinema, and I wanted to reprint it for those of you who have never seen the film (or haven’t seen it in a long time). OWS is about everyday people being mad as hell with the economic and political system, with being ripped off, pissed on, treated like children, and being completely excluded from the bounty of the 1%. What’s the mystery?
Network remains pertinent, timely, throughout. At first, the network powers-that-be are furious. But when they discover that millions of people from coast to coast are in fact yelling out their windows, they realize that Beale has hit a nerve – and they can capitalize on it! They take Beale off the nightly news and give him a show of his own. They call him “The Mad Prophet of the Airwaves.” And the old man comes out each week, gives a powerful rant, then swoons into a dead faint as the audience cheers. Reality TV 36 years before its time!
But in art as in life, one day Beale goes too far. Voicing the rage of the common man (which can always be ignored…) is one thing – but challenging the machinations of BIG big business is quite another. Here’s what Beale says that gets him into trouble:
“All right, listen to me! Listen carefully! This is your goddam life I’m talking about today! In this country, when one company takes over another company, they simply buy up a controlling share of the stock. But first they have to file notice with the government. That’s how C.C. and A. – the Communications Corporation of America – bought up the company that owns this network. And now somebody’s buying up C.C. and A! Some company named Western World Funding Corporation is buying up C.C. and A! They filed their notice this morning! Well, just who the hell is Western World Funding Corporation? It’s a consortium of banks and insurance companies who are not buying C.C. and A. for themselves but as agents for somebody else! Well, who’s this somebody else? They won’t tell you! They won’t tell you, they won’t tell the Senate, they won’t tell the SEC, the FCC, the Justice Department, they wont tell anybody! They say it’s none of our business! The hell it ain’t!”
This is the daily business reality that affects all of us. This is the chicanery that OWS is mad about. What’s the mystery?
Beale can’t be allowed to go on telling that kind of truth. So Arthur Jensen himself (beautifully played by Ned Beatty), the corporate honcho of C.C. and A., takes Beale into an imposing conference room and reads him the corporate riot act. Doesn’t this, too, sound very much like the global economic present – the era that OWS is mad about? Just substitute China for Russia and the corporations of today for those of yesteryear and it’s enough to make you shiver.
Jensen says:
“You have meddled with the primal forces of nature, Mr. Beale, and I won’t have it, is that clear?!...You are an old man who thinks in terms of nations and peoples. There are no nations! There are no peoples! There are no Russians! There are no Arabs! There are no third worlds! There is no West! There is only one holistic system of systems, one vast and… interwoven, interacting, multi-variate, multi-national dominion of dollars! petro-dollars, electro-dollars, multi-dollars!, Reich marks, rubles, rin, pounds and shekels! It is the international system of currency that determines the totality of life on this planet!
“That is the natural order of things today! That is the atomic, subatomic and galactic structure of things today! And you have meddled with the primal forces of nature, and you will atone! Am I getting through to you, Mr. Beale?
“You get up on your little twenty-one inch screen, and howl about America and democracy. There is no America. There is no democracy. There is only IBM and ITT and AT&T and DuPont, Dow, Union Carbide and Exxon. Those are the nations of the world today. What do you think the Russians talk about in their councils of state – Karl Marx? They pull out their linear programming charts, statistical decision theories and minimax solutions and compute the price-cost probabilities of their transactions and investments just like we do. We no longer live in a world of nations and ideologies, Mr. Beale. The world is a college of corporations, inexorably determined by the immutable by-laws of business. The world is a business, Mr. Beale! It has been since man crawled out of the slime…”
This post has gone on long enough I think. I hope you’ve enjoyed these golden snippets of Network and suffice it to say that you should think twice about the invectives being hurled at the OWS: they’re radicals, they’re killers, they’re anti-Semites, they’re a bunch of dirty hippies taking up space.
No. They’re you and me and everyone in the country, who, for one (or more) countless reasons is mad as hell and won’t take it any more. I hope New York has a mild winter.
Every time I watch a movie that shows the New York skyline before the attacks of September 11, 2001, I gasp a little. Sometimes I tear up, other times I feel like I’ve been punched in the stomach – again. I don’t often consciously think about that day and its awful myriad of consequences. But when I see an image of the old skyline, with what now look like magnificent giant rectangles (buildings that prior to 9/11 I frankly thought were an ugly, charmless, over-the-top eyesore), all the shock and sadness come rushing back. I’m an American and a New Yorker and far from immune to the feeling and memory of that horror.
Much has happened in the ten years since. In part, I feel as Dick Cavett described in his New York Times column on 9/9/11: “Have you, perchance, decided — as I have — not to spend the weekend re-wallowing in 9/11 with the media?” Yet I also believe that 9/11 should not be forgotten, and that we still have much to learn and understand about that event.
So the bells and bagpipes ring hollow when I consider that “ground zero” remained a gaping hole in the ground for nearly a decade before a fitting memorial was constructed/landscaped, and an inexplicably taller, larger, monstrosity was erected in place of the original monoliths. (Think what might have been a better use of that land – a new Museum of American History, or a new SUNY or CUNY school. But that wouldn’t have been “commercially viable.” That downtown land is too valuable to squander on education, beauty and fresh air!)
What I think of most these days when I do ponder 9/11 is the unconscionable treatment of the First Responders and clean-up volunteers. In many instances, their courage and generosity have been rewarded with serious illness, but their right to financial compensation and the very best health care that they shouldn’t have to pay a nickel for is consistently questioned and frequently denied.
It’s the same mistreatment of those we also hail as heroes with the “We Support the Troops” crap: flags and parades and medals, but young men and women being routinely sent into harm’s way without proper/necessary equipment of many kinds; being subjected to numerous tours (three, four and more) instead of the traditional one or two; being paid so little that thousands of military families live in sub-standard housing and require Welfare and food stamps; and when they return, being subjected to poor or no health care and unwarranted scrutiny of the “cause” of their injuries!
Very few 9/11 First Responders and volunteers will be part of official tenth anniversary ceremonies today, an insult that speaks (screams) for itself.
I also think of that famous quote: “Those who would sacrifice liberty for security deserve neither liberty nor security” (variously attributed to Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson and Thomas Paine). So when I think of 9/11 now, ten years later, I think of the Patriot Act, a brutal attack on civil rights and legal procedure that citizens have accepted without question in the name of security, just as we accept the imposition of airport and other security measures that appear to do little more than continually close the proverbial barn door. Perhaps our two most traumatic responses have been our loss of innocence and sense of safety, and, the terror of being violated in a way that the mainland of America has never been violated before.
The 1991 film Thelma and Louise came to mind within the last couple of weeks in regard to another matter. Then the film “just happened” to be on TV last night and I began thinking about it in relation to 9/11. Since the movie is 20 years old, I won’t consider myself a “spoiler” if I recap the essence of the story.
Thelma, an obedient, ditzy little housewife and Louise, a capable and emotionally scarred waitress, set off for a weekend vacation in the mountains. For Thelma, their stop at a honky-tonk bar leads to too much drinking, a little suggestive dancing, and an attempted rape by a nasty good-ole-boy in the parking lot. For Louise, armed with her friend’s gun, it leads to a flashback of being raped herself, a verbal altercation with the attempted rapist, and her shooting him dead.
From that moment on, these two ordinary little gals from Arkansas zoom through a series of new incarnations – from frightened victims to brazen criminals to avenging Amazon warriors. They shed their feminine propriety for a “macha” kind of chutzpa and discover a comfortable new wildness in themselves.
Even before they’re surrounded by an army of police, they acknowledge their transformation to each other. “I can’t go back,” says Thelma, “something’s crossed over in me. I just couldn’t live.” “I know what you mean,” answers Louise. So by the time they’re cornered fugitives, they would sooner die than be defiled by a system that would never have believed or helped them. They don’t go back. They clasp hands and drive their car over the edge of the Grand Canyon.
I think something like that happened to America and Americans after 9/11. We lost our innocence along with the sense of safety that comes with being powerful. First we got scared and allowed an opportunistic government to curtail our freedoms. Then we got mad and consented by general silence to two ill-advised wars that are still raging. Then finally, we had enough.
Some of us expressed our rage and need for positive change by electing Barack Obama. Others created the Tea Party. We all “want our country back,” by which we mean many different things. Hardcore conservatives want to get the black president out of the White House, not pay taxes and move back to Mayberry. Hardcore liberals want a sane, engaged government that’s got our backs; we want justice for all and to give peace a chance. We all want to go back to what we personally recall as the best part of the 20th century, the American century.
But we can’t go back. Something’s crossed over in us all.
MizB is a single, 67-year-old, born-and-bred New Yorker, raised in the Bronx and (primarily) Brooklyn by her White/Jewish mother and Black (West Indian)/Episcopalian father; she steadfastly considers herself biracial. She is an Old School Liberal who participated in the major human rights movements of her time: Civil Rights, Women’s Rights, anti-Vietnam War, and Gay Rights. She is greatly distressed by the stupidity, rigidity and meanness of contemporary politics. She is a secular Jew and a spiritual appreciator of the life and cosmic mysteries for which we have no answers. She is an ordained Interfaith Minister of Spiritual Counseling as well as a certified Professional Tarot Reader. She has no sense of connection to animals, nature or children. She hugely dislikes the majority of communications technology and social media that have taken over the world's hearts, capacity to think, and to use language effectively. She is an unrepentant cigarette smoker (makes her own) and is not ashamed of being fat! She loves actual paper books, 60s folk music, rock'n'roll, and folk/rock, detective fiction, really old movies, public television, smart stand-up comedy, and great food of all kinds. She is passionate about language and hates the way it is being increasingly degraded, devalued, and replaced with symbols and acronyms. MizB is a nice woman with a wonderful sense of humor, but an admitted curmudgeon - and with every passing year, she finds herself changing in profound and multiple ways.