I published the post below in 2009. I planned to write a new one this year, but when I read the old one, I realized I didn't need to. The old one still applies. Obviously, some of the statistics have changed: there are now more dead, more very seriously wounded, 22 service-men and women now commit suicide daily, veterans still not receiving adequate physical and mental health care, more veterans and their families living in or near poverty, more homeless veterans, and more unemployed and under-employed returning veterans.
As I explain below, many Americans don't know that Memorial Day honors the military dead, while Veterans Day honors the military living. It seems to me that except for waving flags and exclaiming "We support the troops!" most people don't do a damn thing to honor the military, whether living or dead. And I also think the best way we as citizens, and the government that sends men and women off to war, could best honor the dead is by doing a whole lot better for the living. It doesn't matter whether we support current or past wars (Vietnam veterans are still suffering greatly) or even think some of our veterans committed horrific acts. They were either drafted or signed up (a) because they believed they were doing right by the USA or (b) had no where to go in civilian life and thought the military could give them a skill or an education that would prepare them for a productive, self-supporting civilian life afterwards, and in the meantime they were being brave and useful.
This country is severely messed up in a lot of ways and these problems are serious and have no easy solutions. But without a doubt, how/why/when we go to war, then how we treat our returning warriors, is one of the sickest situations we need to deal with. So, on Monday, May 25, 2015, by all means say a prayer or a respectful atheistic thank you to and for the dead. But more importantly, find some time this summer to write to your Senators, Congressional Representatives, and the President and let them know you want to see vastly improved benefits and services of all kinds for living veterans. The dead don't need our showy, basically meaningless tributes. But the living need and deserve our respect, our appreciation, and all practical support and privileges our humongous Defense budget can provide.
____________________________
Having just watched the 20
th annual
National Memorial Day Concert on PBS,
I feel compelled to say: let us indeed remember and honor those
military men and women who died in defense of this country, from the
Revolutionary War over 200 years ago to yesterday in Iraq and
Afghanistan. But let us also add some genuine meaning to the putrid
schmaltz that comprised the majority of this holiday special by creating
a new standard for patriotic pride, one that advocates peace and
diplomacy, and demands that our government also honor those who fought
and managed to survive, by giving them all the medical care &
therapy, financial benefits, education & training, housing,
family assistance, and anything else they need or want,
because no matter how much they get, it’s still much less than they deserve.
I
understand that because we are in the midst of active war on two grisly
fronts, it is appropriate on Memorial Day 2009 to acknowledge living
veterans – particularly those severely wounded and those (largely)
intact who have served in our current wars. That said, one of my
longstanding civic pet peeves is that so many flag-waving Americans
don’t know the difference between Memorial Day and Veterans Day, so let
me make that distinction clear for anyone who may be confused.
Memorial
Day, formerly known as Decoration Day, was first commemorated in 1868
to honor the military dead of the Civil War and continues to be the
holiday that honors all war dead, held on the last Monday of May each
year. Veterans Day, formerly known as Armistice Day because it
commemorated the end of World War I on November 11, 1918, is the day we
honor military veterans (war survivors) of all wars in which Americans
participated, and it is held on November 11
th
each year, no matter what day of the week it falls on. For decades,
both holidays have been primarily viewed by the oh-so-patriotic populace
as occasions to go shopping, and, in the case of Memorial Day,
participate in cook-outs and start wearing white for the summer.
My
grandfather was a wounded veteran of World War I and received several
medals. My father was a Merchant Marine veteran of World War II, during
which he survived two major fires on two different oil tankers. My uncle
is a WWII Navy veteran who served in the Pacific. And over the years,
I’
ve had
friends who served in the Army, Navy and Marines, including a lesbian
who was drummed out of the Navy during a gay witch-hunt in the 50s. I
may be a 60s
peacenik,
but I have never disrespected war veterans, and, I’m proud to say, was
never among those who greeted returning Vietnam War veterans with shouts
of “baby killers!”
Throughout history, some wars have
been morally necessary, others were totally contrived for cynical, often
purely economic reasons. But all of them wounded and/or killed persons
who (very often) voluntarily put themselves in harm’s way, because they
believed they were doing something essential in defense of their country
and the values for which it stands. This is true of the military
personnel of all countries, whether they’re our allies or our enemies.
And for a while, there were Rules of War, a perhaps
oxymoronic
concept that said “this form of brutality is allowed, but this other
form is not.” Among those rules at various times were Don’t Kill
Civilians, Don’t Attack Hospitals and Schools, and Don’t Torture
Prisoners of War. I think it can be fairly said that the gloves have
been off on all those fronts for some years now, and America is hardly
alone in this regard.
But to return to the purpose of
Memorial Day: one of the great ironies of modern warfare is that
battlefield medicine has been so enormously improved, many of those who
would have died of horrendous injuries in wars gone by are now patched
up sufficiently to make it home, only to endure countless surgeries,
tortuous physical rehab, and existence of either lifeless vegetation or
grossly limiting disability. Is this progress or torment? I imagine that
those with severe, lifelong injuries have different opinions;
unfortunately for them, many of them can't tell anyone what their true
wishes are.
It’s worth noting here that (as of April
2009, per About.com) 4,278 military personnel have so far died in Iraq
and Afghanistan; and 31,215 have been wounded, most of them severely and
20% with completely life-altering brain or spinal injuries. Salon.com
reports that 30% of returning troops develop serious mental/emotional
problems within 3 to 4 months of their return, and 140 veterans of the
Army alone have committed suicide – a trend that is increasing by all
accounts. It is also worth noting that through mid-2009, $800 billion
has been spent on the Iraq and Afghanistan Wars and President Obama
recently requested another $76 billion. It costs over $300,000 per year
to deploy one soldier. All facts worth remembering this Memorial Day.
One of the few musical moments in tonight’s concert that
didn’t
prompt me to roll my eyes with nausea or despair came from country
music singer Trace Adkins. He sang a beautiful, plaintive song called
“`Til the Last Shot’s Fired,” the chorus of which says:
Say a prayer
for peace/For every fallen son/Set my spirit free/Let me lay down my
gun/Sweet Mother Mary, I’m so tired/But I can’t come home/`Til the last
shot’s fired. Let’s honor the war dead – and the war survivors – by
finding a way to fire the last shot; to finding new and better ways
besides war to stop tyranny and other ills in their insidious tracks.